TY - JOUR
T1 - Data quality control considerations in multivariate environmental monitoring
T2 - experience of the French coastal network SOMLIT
AU - Breton, Elsa
AU - Savoye, Nicolas
AU - Rimmelin-Maury, Peggy
AU - Sautour, Benoit
AU - Goberville, Eric
AU - Lheureux, Arnaud
AU - Cariou, Thierry
AU - Ferreira, Sophie
AU - Agogué, Hélène
AU - Alliouane, Samir
AU - Aubert, Fabien
AU - Aubin, Sébastien
AU - Berthebaud, Eric
AU - Blayac, Hadrien
AU - Blondel, Lucie
AU - Boulart, Cédric
AU - Bozec, Yann
AU - Bureau, Sarah
AU - Caillo, Arnaud
AU - Cauvin, Arnaud
AU - Cazes, Jean Baptiste
AU - Chasselin, Léo
AU - Claquin, Pascal
AU - Conan, Pascal
AU - Cordier, Marie Ange
AU - Costes, Laurence
AU - Crec’hriou, Romain
AU - Crispi, Olivier
AU - Crouvoisier, Muriel
AU - David, Valérie
AU - Del Amo, Yolanda
AU - De Lary, Hortense
AU - Delebecq, Gaspard
AU - Devesa, Jeremy
AU - Domeau, Aurélien
AU - Durozier, Maria
AU - Emery, Claire
AU - Feunteun, Eric
AU - Fauchot, Juliette
AU - Gentilhomme, Valérie
AU - Geslin, Sandrine
AU - Giraud, Mélanie
AU - Grangeré, Karine
AU - Grégori, Gerald
AU - Grossteffan, Emilie
AU - Gueux, Aurore
AU - Guillaudeau, Julien
AU - Guillou, Gael
AU - Harrewyn, Manon
AU - Jolly, Orianne
AU - Jude-Lemeilleur, Florence
AU - Labatut, Paul
AU - Labourdette, Nathalie
AU - Lachaussée, Nicolas
AU - Lafont, Michel
AU - Lagadec, Veronique
AU - Lambert, Christophe
AU - Lamoureux, Jezebel
AU - Lanceleur, Laurent
AU - Lebreton, Benoit
AU - Lecuyer, Eric
AU - Lemeille, David
AU - Leredde, Yann
AU - Leroux, Cédric
AU - Leynaert, Aude
AU - L’Helguen, Stéphane
AU - Liénart, Camilla
AU - Macé, Eric
AU - Maria, Eric
AU - Marie, Barbara
AU - Marie, Dominique
AU - Mas, Sébastien
AU - Mendes, Fabrice
AU - Mornet, Line
AU - Mostajir, Behzad
AU - Mousseau, Laure
AU - Nowaczyk, Antoine
AU - Nunige, Sandra
AU - Parra, René
AU - Paulin, Thomas
AU - Pecqueur, David
AU - Petit, Franck
AU - Pineau, Philippe
AU - Raimbault, Patrick
AU - Rigaut-Jalabert, Fabienne
AU - Salmeron, Christophe
AU - Salter, Ian
AU - Sauriau, Pierre Guy
AU - Seuront, Laurent
AU - Sultan, Emmanuelle
AU - Valdès, Rémi
AU - Vantrepotte, Vincent
AU - Vidussi, Francesca
AU - Voron, Florian
AU - Vuillemin, Renaud
AU - Zudaire, Laurent
AU - Garcia, Nicole
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
Copyright © 2023 Breton, Savoye, Rimmelin-Maury, Sautour, Goberville, Lheureux, Cariou, Ferreira, Agogué, Alliouane, Aubert, Aubin, Berthebaud, Blayac, Blondel, Boulart, Bozec, Bureau, Caillo, Cauvin, Cazes, Chasselin, Claquin, Conan, Cordier, Costes, Crec’hriou, Crispi, Crouvoisier, David, Del Amo, De Lary, Delebecq, Devesa, Domeau, Durozier, Emery, Feunteun, Fauchot, Gentilhomme, Geslin, Giraud, Grangeré, Grégori, Grossteffan, Gueux, Guillaudeau, Guillou, Harrewyn, Jolly, Jude-Lemeilleur, Labatut, Labourdette, Lachaussée, Lafont, Lagadec, Lambert, Lamoureux, Lanceleur, Lebreton, Lecuyer, Lemeille, Leredde, Leroux, Leynaert, L’Helguen, Liénart, Macé, Maria, Marie, Marie, Mas, Mendes, Mornet, Mostajir, Mousseau, Nowaczyk, Nunige, Parra, Paulin, Pecqueur, Petit, Pineau, Raimbault, Rigaut-Jalabert, Salmeron, Salter, Sauriau, Seuront, Sultan, Valdès, Vantrepotte, Vidussi, Voron, Vuillemin, Zudaire and Garcia.
PY - 2023
Y1 - 2023
N2 - Introduction: While crucial to ensuring the production of accurate and high-quality data—and to avoid erroneous conclusions—data quality control (QC) in environmental monitoring datasets is still poorly documented. Methods: With a focus on annual inter-laboratory comparison (ILC) exercises performed in the context of the French coastal monitoring SOMLIT network, we share here a pragmatic approach to QC, which allows the calculation of systematic and random errors, measurement uncertainty, and individual performance. After an overview of the different QC actions applied to fulfill requirements for quality and competence, we report equipment, accommodation, design of the ILC exercises, and statistical methodology specially adapted to small environmental networks (<20 laboratories) and multivariate datasets. Finally, the expanded uncertainty of measurement for 20 environmental variables routinely measured by SOMLIT from discrete sampling—including Essential Ocean Variables—is provided. Results, Discussion, Conclusion: The examination of the temporal variations (2001–2021) in the repeatability, reproducibility, and trueness of the SOMLIT network over time confirms the essential role of ILC exercises as a tool for the continuous improvement of data quality in environmental monitoring datasets.
AB - Introduction: While crucial to ensuring the production of accurate and high-quality data—and to avoid erroneous conclusions—data quality control (QC) in environmental monitoring datasets is still poorly documented. Methods: With a focus on annual inter-laboratory comparison (ILC) exercises performed in the context of the French coastal monitoring SOMLIT network, we share here a pragmatic approach to QC, which allows the calculation of systematic and random errors, measurement uncertainty, and individual performance. After an overview of the different QC actions applied to fulfill requirements for quality and competence, we report equipment, accommodation, design of the ILC exercises, and statistical methodology specially adapted to small environmental networks (<20 laboratories) and multivariate datasets. Finally, the expanded uncertainty of measurement for 20 environmental variables routinely measured by SOMLIT from discrete sampling—including Essential Ocean Variables—is provided. Results, Discussion, Conclusion: The examination of the temporal variations (2001–2021) in the repeatability, reproducibility, and trueness of the SOMLIT network over time confirms the essential role of ILC exercises as a tool for the continuous improvement of data quality in environmental monitoring datasets.
KW - analyst performance
KW - data quality control
KW - environmental monitoring network
KW - inter-laboratory comparison exercises
KW - measurement uncertainty
KW - multivariate dataset
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85159111845&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.3389/fmars.2023.1135446
DO - 10.3389/fmars.2023.1135446
M3 - Artículo
AN - SCOPUS:85159111845
SN - 2296-7745
VL - 10
JO - Frontiers in Marine Science
JF - Frontiers in Marine Science
M1 - 1135446
ER -